Have you ever been faced with an issue while reading or blogging and thought: I wonder what other bloggers think about this? No matter what genre or audience you blog for, we all face the same problems. Are you a publisher or author wondering what goes on in a blogger's (and by extension a reader's) head?
Blogger confidential is a series of 10 questions asked to 13 bloggers about the nitty gritty details of blogging. Everything from what prompts a blogger to pick up a book, to what happens when a book doesn't live up to its hype. This series was inspired by
Wastepaper Prose's Author Insight series. Learn more about the Blogger Confidential series
on its main page.
Do you accept self-published books for review? Why or why not? If not, is the turn-off in the pitch or the product itself?
"I don't accept self-published books and it does have to do with the product itself. It's usually not been edited thoroughly and is riddled with errors, plus I talk with other bloggers who have accepted self-published books and they usually don't like them either, wondering why they agreed to it in the first place. It also just has to do with the fact that I have a ton of traditionally published books in my pile and don't have time to add on something that isn't and that may end up being a waste of my time."
James from Book Chic
"We have in our review policy we will accept self-published titles for review. It all depends on the book. We’ve only ever accepted one and it was something we thought we would like and we noticed other bloggers/reviewers who had liked this particular book. I’m unaware as to why many bloggers won’t review self-published books, but we have no reason not to review them."
Jacinda and Jasmine from The Reading Housewives of Indiana
"I used to accept self published books but I’ve been burnt every time as usually the writing/editing is not the highest quality which is a shame. I think self published books are a bit of a turn off because of the fact that anyone can go and publish something they have written but if it is published by one of the big publishing houses, you can expect a certain level of quality whereas with a self published book, it’s pot luck."
Lynsey from Narratively Speaking
"I do accept them for review normally but I have become too swamped with other review books that I stopped accepting them for a while."
Katie from Katie's Book Blog
"Yes! We are proud that we read self-published books - there’s gold in them thar hills."
Stacy, Shannan, Nancy, and Sarah from Girls in the Stacks
We used to – but lately we have been swamped with main stream books and there has been a lot of drama surrounding self published book reviews and authors. We just thought it would be wiser not to review self published books. We will make exceptions, if there is a book we feel strongly about reading like
Rosie by Mariam Maarouf (a teen Egyptian YA author that Stacey came across during the recent Egyptian revolution).
Pixie and Stacey from Page Turners Blog
"As a general rule, I don’t – and this is mostly due to some bad experiences in the past. I hate making sweeping generalizations, but for the most part (in my experience), most self-pubbed books were self-published for a reason. That is, they just weren’t good enough for traditional publishing. Likewise, I’ve had some bad experiences with self-pubbed authors getting very cranky and rude when they disliked my honest review of their work. However, I will always consider a self-pubbed book if it’s recommended to me from a reliable source. For example, I just read Sleight by Jennifer Sommersby on a friend’s recommendation, and I’m so glad I did. Here’s an exception to my generalization about self-publishing. This was a GREAT book, and I’m really excited to share it with visitors to Novel Novice. And it’s because of books like Sleight that I don’t have a hard & fast rule about self-published books."
Sara from Novel Novice
"I used to. But I don't anymore. It's mostly the product. Overall, and I hate to generalize because I know it's not to for every single self-pubbed book, but they are just lacking in the qualities that make a book a good read for me. There are other reasons that are more personal for me, but mostly it's a quality issue."
Kristi from The Story Siren
"Yes I have before, I don't take as many now due to the fact that I have a larger amount of review books arrive from publishers, but when ever one of us on the blog has some spare time we try and help out a self-published author."
Yara from Once Upon a Twilight
"I don’t. I get a lot of requests to review self-pubs (even though it says I don’t on my blog) and they come in two varieties:
1) A mass-email that was clearly sent to a hundred other people.
2) A very nice and personalized e-mail. This is where the author says they know my blog and love it (often citing specific things) and would I please give their book a chance?
I don’t even reply to the #1s. Pretty sure they don’t notice, anyway. I reply to the #2s, but always in the negative. This is a relatively new development. I used to take self-pubs from authors who sent me style #2 requests, but it just got too awkward. Self-pubs and indie-pubs usually don’t have an editor at all, or they don’t have the kind of editor that they need. I’ve never been able to honestly say that I loved a self-pub (most I don’t even finish), and then it breaks my heart. What do I do? Do I just not review it? Do I give it a negative review and risk the author seeing it? This just became too difficult, so I don’t do it anymore."
Enna from Squeaky Books
"I don't. I'm going to sound really snotty right now, but I'll say it anyway. Most self-published books I've gotten are frankly not very good, so I don't take them anymore. I'm positive that there are plenty that are spectacular, but I have no desire to be a slush-pile reader. There are so many publishers (including small publishers) out there that I automatically wonder about books that have not been picked up by any sort of publishing company."
Wallace from Unputdownables
"No, I do not. I find that the quality is lacking; If they can’t submit it to a professional for editing, why should I spend my time reading it for review? I don’t let it get past the pitch; If I see the book is self-published, I delete the pitch. My review policy clearly states that I do not review self-published books. It’s not up to interpretation."
Jenn from Jenn's Bookshelves
"I absolutely accept self-published books for review on Reading Vacation. I do not think it matters whether a book was published by a big name or by the author. It is what is on the inside that counts. All stories deserve a chance. Oh, and some of those self-published books are really good too."
Melina from Reading Vacation